A note before you listen
This episode discusses allegations of sexual misconduct in the media, sexual harassment at work, depression and antidepressant medication, and includes some strong language. Please do not stop or change any medication without talking to your doctor first.
Show notes
The Concept of the Week is the generation effect: we remember what we work out for ourselves better than what we simply read or hear. It is why writing down the answer to your maths homework beats a laptop that says "Correct", and the Psych Hack follows from it: before you look something up, have a guess first.
Jensen Huang has resigned as Nvidia's chief executive after admitting he had been unfaithful, and Nvidia's shares fell sharply. Hilary asks what makes a secret so delicious. Peter's answer is that very few people keep a secret to themselves: secrets are social currency, and part of the pleasure is that someone else knows. He explains Robin Dunbar's idea that language took over from grooming as the way we keep our social networks together, which is why gossip round the campfire matters so much, and why being the last to know feels so bad.
The Metropolitan Police is investigating allegations against David Walliams, which he denies, and comedian Lucy Beaumont has spoken about raising concerns. Hilary and Peter talk about why celebrity power and a fragmented TV industry make safeguarding so hard: a big name can be worth tens of millions to a programme, there is no single place where allegations are recorded, and production companies can fold and start again. Peter explains why he will not screen reality TV contestants for "resilience", why he thinks the Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy is right to consider making industry standards compulsory, and why, from his own research in care homes, enforcement changes culture faster than training does.
A new review in The Lancet Psychiatry compares antidepressants for long-term use. Peter, who sat on the NICE committee for the depression guideline, is sceptical of the idea that depression is caused by a chemical imbalance and explains what SSRIs do in the brain, why he thinks stopping them can feel like a relapse when it is the effect of the drug, and why coming off should always be slow and done with medical advice. Then what else helps: exercise, talking therapies and, one day perhaps, psychedelic-assisted therapy.
If anything in this episode has affected you
Samaritans are there day or night on 116 123. If you are thinking about coming off antidepressants, talk to your GP or prescriber first.
Concept of the Week: Generation effect
The generation effect. Things you generate yourself, you remember better than things you only read or hear. Slamecka and Graf showed it in 1978: people who completed a word themselves remembered it better than people who simply read it.
The Triple T: have a guess first
Mentioned in this episode
- The generation effect, Slamecka and Graf (1978): Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory
- Robin Dunbar's Grooming, Gossip and the Evolution of Language (1996): Wikipedia
- The psychology of secrets, including how often secrets are passed on: The Psychologist
- Three antidepressants may be best for long-term treatment, on the November 2026 Lancet Psychiatry review: Medical News Today
- The serotonin theory of depression, an umbrella review by Moncrieff and colleagues (2022): Molecular Psychiatry
- Tapering antidepressants, Horowitz and Taylor (2019): The Lancet Psychiatry
- Depression in adults, the NICE guideline: NICE NG222
- Antidepressants and depression, the Royal College of Psychiatrists position statement (2019): RCPsych
Full transcript (11,117 words)
Transcript generated from the recording and lightly edited for readability. Timings refer to the audio episode. If you spot an error, write to hello@experiencepodco.com.
Peter Kinderman And the thing about language is that then you don't spend so much time picking nits out of people's hair. What you do is you sit round the campfire going, "Have you heard about George? Apparently he's cheating on his wife again." It is a much, much, much more efficient way of maintaining social relationships, which is why the social network of humans is massive and the social network of monkeys is small.
Hilary Jeffs Hello, and welcome to the latest episode of Experience, the podcast where we explore human behavior by psychoanalyzing the news. Coming up on today's show, we will have the concept of the week and psych hack, and we'll also be discussing sex, spies, and ticker tape, as stock markets dropped worldwide because of Nvidia boss Jensen Huang stepping down after what looks like a honey trap and some other sex demeanours, meaning we'll be discussing with Peter the lure of a secret. Also on the way, Walliams' wanting, or Walliams' wantonness. He hit the headlines and has got onto police radar as well. So we're gonna look at safeguarding in the media. And last but not least, a new report was out about antidepressants, and it was looking as to which one is better for the longer term. So we'll look at that data and also some other evidence-based ways that you can use to improve your mood. But what we really need you to do is to like and subscribe our pod and tell your friends about us too, because we're an independent podcast company. But we've got some exciting news. We're about to launch a new sister pod called Conversations with Experience, and we would like to hear from you. So we're looking for some guest experts to chat through what well-being, well-being means to them. So if you know someone who works in mental health or well-being, or indeed where their own experiences have informed how they work and how they live, then please tell us more. You can email us on hello@experiencepodco.com. Hopefully, in the next few weeks, we will be joined by Cal Jones from Hapus Yogi, and he wants to discuss some pretty big topics, including are we simply a summation of all of our experiences? And also, can we use ancient solutions to solve modern-day problems? So that's Conversations with Experience, and it's going to appear alongside this episode in your normal Experience feed wherever you get your podcasts. But of course, I cannot do these mental marathons on my own. Each week, I am joined by our very own resident expert, the wonderful professor of psychology, Peter Kinderman. Peter, so why were you so keen for us to do this new show?
Peter Kinderman Because, well, to be perfectly honest, because there's a possibility of sitting in front of a, well, in this case, a laptop, a camera and a microphone and pontificating without getting any feedback. And feedback is crucial. Feedback is how we all live. Feedback is important in my clinical profession. You know, you say something, but it's not a statement of fact, it's a suggestion that the person might bounce off. You set up a hypothesis in science and you test it. You have some ideas about the world, and you go and do an experiment and see whether it's true. So you can't sit and pontificate about anything. And, you know, as it-- I suppose in the Buddhist tradition, the world is constantly changing, so anything that we say that's true today will be untrue tomorrow. And the way to resolve that is get some feedback, talk to people, bounce ideas off people, and move forward. Otherwise, otherwise it's just you saying that I'm an expert and me saying that I'm brilliant, and I quite like that, and that's bad for me
Hilary Jeffs Okay, good. So we're hoping for some critical challenge along the way, which is good. And of course, as someone wise once said, there's more than one way to skin a cat. And actually, the more information that we get about how we can improve wellbeing, it might work for someone. It may work for one of us as well, because we're all a bit different, and different things work for different people
Peter Kinderman I also have a sort of profound belief. I have this belief about psychotherapy and the world of clinical psychology, which is if lots of things appear to be working, there's probably some sort of underlying principle that hangs it all together. So if it's a good idea to talk to somebody about your difficulties, and if it's a good idea to do exercise, and if it's a good idea to sit in the sun, what's the underlying principle or principles that make all of those things worthwhile things to do? So I like the idea of-- Well, I mean, I've said, as I've said to you before, it's therapeutic to think about things from different perspectives. And, I was, I was talking to my wife about, why we like some people and they become friends, and I think it's often the branching conversations of I say something and they go, "Ooh, yes. Now that reminded me of the time where I actually did try to skin a cat." And I go, " What? You've tried to skin a cat?" And then they say, "No." And then, so the conversation goes bodging. If they go, "I'm a chartered accountant," I go, "Is chartered accountant fun?" And they go, "No, but it pays a decent wage with an average to good pension at the end of it." I just think this conversation is going nowhere. But the ones that spiral and branch and bifurcate just give you more about the world.
Hilary Jeffs There are people in plenty of professions who are really, really boring. And may I just speak up for chartered accountants that I know quite a number of them, they're a little bit rock and roll, so you can't judge a book
Peter Kinderman It's also, yeah, I know very, very, very large number of very, very boring clinical psychologists that I try to avoid at conferences
Hilary Jeffs Well, they will now be trying to
Peter Kinderman I could name them.
Hilary Jeffs Well because they're gonna be worried about being
Peter Kinderman I could name them with imp- with impunity
Hilary Jeffs No, let's not be cruel. We could all name some boring people, but it is just better to hold our counsel.
Peter Kinderman I ju- I'll just give you acronyms. No, not acronyms, initials.
Hilary Jeffs Initials. Oh no, it's like gonna be like a boring psychologist t- travel hunt or something. No, no, no, we can't do that. Right, before we crack on with the headlines, Peter, what is our concept of the week this week?
Peter Kinderman So the concept of the week is really simple, and it kind of applies to everybody, and we all kind of know it, but again, yet again, psychology's given a name to it, which is the generation effect. Things that you generate yourself you remember better than things that are just, you know, that you just perceive. And this is the principle behind getting 12-year-olds to actually write down the answers to their maths homework. Because if you do the maths homework and you go, you know, there's a complicated equation, A squared plus B plus 3C, and you hit the button on the laptop because they're all automated now, and it goes, "Correct," and then you move on to the next. You haven't learned anything. But if you write it down on a piece of paper, because you've generated the answer, the generation of the answer means that you remember things better. So for nearly everything, if you generate it... People do this all the time where they go, "Car keys, car keys, car keys, car keys," and they're telling themselves it's car keys. Partly it keeps it in the auditory loop, but partly it's generation. So lots of us, I mean, certainly my friends, I mean, I don't know everybody else, it's not a question I've asked in a survey, but you write things down in notebooks, to-do lists, all of this sort of stuff. That's because when you generate things, you remember them. And then,
Hilary Jeffs No, no, no. What it is because then you can put a line through it, and I am someone who likes to write down things I've done on my to-do list just so I can scratch them out, which is a little bit sad. But when you said generation effect, I literally thought it was gonna be that whole idea of learning from other people, but actually it's the exact opposite. It's about making sure that you're doing stuff yourself so that, you know, you remember it more widely
Peter Kinderman Yeah, and it's, it's, it's almost certainly to do with... Although I've just, those sort of examples I've given, they're quite intellectual. It's almost certainly to do with the fact that what we're doing when we're doing the business of remembering is it's associative networks. So that's what it is. So the idea of having an association between a word and a concept, you know, there is a neural pathway, so those concepts are associated. And of course, if we've put energy into, you know, sharpening the stick and putting the stick on the shelf and then polishing the stick and then having a good conversation with people about the stick, then all of those pathways about the stick have been, you know,... You're, you're laughing at me, but
Hilary Jeffs you at a dinner party next to a chartered accountant where you're talking about a sharpened stick on your shelf whilst they're saying, "And I've got a really good pension, thanks very much."
Peter Kinderman Yeah. The problem I've found in my career is that I often have ideas and then I think about kind of three or four things that are associated with that idea, and then I say one of them and people have lost the link. That's the problem. So the sharpened stick was a throwback to sort of evolutionary psychology and sharpening sticks and muscle memory and associative net- net- networks. But maybe I didn't explain that too well. But you're not a
Hilary Jeffs No, you did. It's just I literally wanted to hear that conversation and to see the looks on each of your faces. Anyway, let's crack on with the headlines. Of course, it is that Huang bang that's wiped billions off the stock market, as Nvidia boss Jensen Huang has had to step down over his affair with Alice Huang, no relation whatsoever, and indeed, other women at his firm that he founded. Of course, over the weekend, we've had lots of billionaires decide to get behind this worthy cause and campaign for him to get his job back. But so far, the board itself has actually managed to decline that. But, we'll just have to see where that p- pans out. But Peter, in A Picture of Dorian Gray, Oscar Wilde wrote about the commonest thing is delightful if only one hides it. Now, by the very nature, affairs and spying, pretty covert, pretty hidden. What is it about a secret? What is it about the lure of a secret that just makes it so delicious? Explain it to us from a psychological point of view
Peter Kinderman I suspect-- well, first of all, that's been noted quite a lot. There's also the idea of the confession and the idea that there are very few people who seem to have secrets that they tell nobody. That's part of the problem. So, you know, people have affairs and then they blab about it on the train and then, you know, it ends terribly. And there's quite a lot of kind of internet stuff where people, I mean, they're, they're, they're lying or they're making it up, but they have this terrible secret and then they decide they're gonna w-write a blog about it, which I find slightly odd. So the fact that people want to talk about their secrets and keep them secret, and the fact that kind of like, "I know, I know information that nobody else knows, and I'm gonna tell the world that I know information that nobody else knows." And this idea that after people have been revealed as having either terrible dark secrets or more juicy secrets that kind of people knew all along. And that indicates, I think, that part of the thing about having secrets is that they're delicious because people like to boast about it. I mean, you know,
Hilary Jeffs so it is social currency. That's what it's all about.
Peter Kinderman I think it's social currency, and I
Hilary Jeffs So it's not the holding of secrets, it's the being able to pass it on, that power of it
Peter Kinderman well, yeah, and it's, it's quite delicious because if you tell everybody that you're having an affair, then obviously it's disaster. If you tell nobody that you're having an affair, well, you know, the sex might be great and you might actually be in
Hilary Jeffs need to at least tell one other person.
Peter Kinderman Well, it's not that you need to. It's that at the back of your mind
Hilary Jeffs no, the person you're having an affair with, unless it's
Peter Kinderman Yeah. So the two of you are then sharing this dig and you're thinking, "Oh, yeah," and there's someone going... And I think there's a lure of, "Ooh, aren't I special?" And, you know, "Don't I have this, don't I have this thing that's going on that's making me special?" And, "Oh, you don't know that," you know, whatever it is that's going on.
Hilary Jeffs But we're told bottling up secrets is bad. Is it bad for you? Is it corrosive, or is there a benefit in holding onto these secrets?
Peter Kinderman Well, as far, as far as I can tell, the main thing going on is-- well, there are several things about secrets. The first is that, of course, keeping secrets is bad in the sense that if it is revealed to the people around you that you have been keeping a secret, then basically that's sending them the message that you've been dishonest, you've been disloyal, or you've been less than open, and that's corrosive for relationships. I guess technically you could say that in that case, it's having a secret revealed that you had kept secret but has now popped out into the open is corrosive for relationships. But you'd have to say, you know, you're running a risk, aren't you? So if you go, "Look, I'm, I'm, I'm fine with secrets as long as they don't get out. So this one is bottled up so tight that even if I was waterboarded, I wouldn't reveal it." You know, and then, then you leave a receipt for a diamond ring on your bedside table and, you know, it comes out. I'm thinking of, Love Actually and that where... Yeah, that. But I think the other thing is that it does, you know, like I say, if people are keeping secrets, their story-- again, it's like the generative effect. It's all associative networks in the brain. So if you've got a whole mass of stuff that's going on in your brain, and you've got a secret, and it's an important secret, even if nobody knows about it, then there's extra stuff in your brain. Most people say that their lives are stressful, and most people, even if they're really, really bored, don't want that kind of extra cognitive effort. They'd quite like a nicer sort of cognitive effort. So it's just like you're carrying around a sort of, a sort of leg iron weight of extra cognition that you don't need
Hilary Jeffs So is this really the psychology of secrets, or is it the psychology of lying? Because actually, secrets don't have to be awful as in you've done something awful that you need to lie about, like an affair. It can be something that you find shameful, or it can be someone else's secret. We know that there is a whole load of China's whispers going on, and not just in the Trump administration about Jensen Huang. You know, there's something like a third of all secrets are passed on and passed around,
Peter Kinderman Well, yeah. So again, you know, so I was saying earlier about, you know, one's secret about oneself or, you know, if you're having a secret affair or if you've found the secret of making money or maybe you've done something criminal and then all that. The- then the sense of the social currency you get from bragging about it is kind of there. But I think that the human beings, because we're social a- so if we go back, right. So human beings or proto-human beings big babies, babies with big brains need a village. We're a social animal. That's what we are. You simply can't have a successful human species where it's kind of one mother and her daughter and, you know, them against the world. You have to have the village, you have to have the extended family, you have to have the tribe, you have to kind of look after each other. In order to do that, what you do is you groom, and then along comes a guy that I actually wrote a paper with once called Robin Dunbar, who's done a lot of work on grooming. And his argument, I think, is a very, very valid one,
Hilary Jeffs We're talking about literal grooming, not
Peter Kinderman W- well, this is the point. So Robin Dunbar's argument, and I think he's almost certainly right, is that the reason why we have language is 'cause we don't literally groom. We have a much, much more efficient way of sitting around the campfire, maintaining our social relationships. If you're a monkey or an ape, apparently apes are types of monkey. I didn't know that, but apparently monkey is the superordinate category and the apes are-- So we are actually monkeys, but there you go.
Hilary Jeffs I didn't know that.
Peter Kinderman Somebody said on a BBC podcast the other day. Anyway, so the monkeys are sitting around and the way that they maintain their social relationships is with punching people occasionally, biting people occasionally, a few shrieks, and a lot of grooming
Hilary Jeffs It just sounds like my household when the kids were
Peter Kinderman No, no, no, no, no. No, because, and here's the thing a few hundred million... Well, no, not v-very many million years ago, but a baby monkey gave birth to a daughter who had two versions of the neural growth hormone, and so her daughter had, just by genetic fluke, a really big brain, and she developed language. And the thing about language is that then you don't spend so much time picking nits out of people's hair. What you do is you sit round the campfire going, "Have you heard about George? Apparently he's cheating on his wife again." It is a much, much, much more efficient way of maintaining social relationships, which is why the social network of humans is massive and the social network of monkeys is small. So we maintain our social relationships through language and through gossip. And a part of gossip is relating to the people that you're gossiping with all of the social networks that keep us going. And it's really important stuff. It's like, you know, "Do not give food to George, he'll give it to his mistress." "All right, well, well, you know, I'll keep the dead marmoset for myself then. Thank you very much. I'm glad you told me that information."
Hilary Jeffs Let's just give a shout-out to Jensen Huang's wife, who used to earn more than him until she decided to take a step back from her career to look after the children. Yes, it's always a joy, isn't it?
Peter Kinderman So keeping secrets, sharing secrets, telling people what's going on in your social network, that's important currency. And in some ways you could argue that, you know, since gossiping about the social relationships of people in our circle of acquaintance is so valuable, the people who know more secrets and are better at gossiping are kind of central to our social
Hilary Jeffs Yeah. Well, I mean, it is that awful feeling that everyone else has known what's going on and you've been the last one to know. I think that is often where any scorn comes, isn't it? You know, the revenge comes is just from that feeling of that you've been stupid or made a fool of. No one likes that, do they?
Peter Kinderman And excluded from the campfire. Ev- everybody else knew and not me. What does that mean? And, you know, if I go to-- if I, if I need a dead marmoset, is anybody going to lend me a dead marmoset? Because I'm, I'm obviously out of the social network. So I think sharing of secrets i- is part of that gossiping and the grooming of social relationships. Probably, you know, it's, it's at the end of the bell curve where, you know, gossiping and social grooming start to descend into being bad things for us.
Hilary Jeffs Yeah, absolutely. Right, let's move on to David Walliams then, father of one, OBE, author of Beast of Buckingham Palace, Bad Dad, The World's Worst Parents, Ratburger, Mr. Stink, Mega Monster. Need I go on? He's in the news for some alleged abuse, of his, of his celebrity, abuse of power. And one of the whistleblowers was comedian Lucy Beaumont, who used to work in a school, which doesn't surprise me at all, because she's all about the safeguarding. She feared that she was gonna be canceled for speaking out about this. And in fact, actually, what's happened is her books have sold out online over the weekend, and we've also found a situation where I think her tour tickets are selling like hotcakes. So that's good to know that things can move forward in a positive way. But before we get started about the safeguarding issues, could you just start off by talking us through the psychology of power and why it leads to abuses of power?
Peter Kinderman If you're developing a TV program, not "Traitors," but, you know, of that ilk, then the producers will be looking around for somebody with a name, somebody that the public will recognise and somebody that the public approve of, because it will make... Well, it makes a, you know, the science of it, the stats of it, the economics of it, is that it makes a massive difference to the income revenue. And in part it's true, and in part it's expectations, because of course it's all advertising revenue. But you can make tens of millions of pounds of difference to the income for a TV program if it has a celebrity name attached to it. And the point is that the agents and the producers and the people themselves know that. So they have enormous power, and what that means is that when they say, "I would like a fresh bottle of water, and get the one with nice tits to bring me the water," then the producers will say, "Yes," because they can't afford to say no.
Hilary Jeffs Yeah.
Peter Kinderman And it's terrible, but it ha- but-
Hilary Jeffs well, and I suppose if you think about other industries, you've usually got perhaps one or two big ego, big star managers within that organisation. Whereas when it comes to the media, you've just got a huge proportion, haven't you? Many more people with big egos and big stars and disproportionate control and power over a project compared to within a normal corporation. Plus, you have an awful lot of young people who know that their CV will be made by being able to attach that star's name to their CV. And it's just like a perfect storm, isn't it? About why you end up with people with lots of power and then loads... And mix them with lots of people who don't, whether it's the public or the junior staffers
Peter Kinderman the other thing about TV industry, and media industry is that unlike other industries, the impact of employment and discrimination law is slightly different because you can say It's very difficult if you're, if you're advertising for a professor of theoretical physics at the University of wherever, and you say, "We want a professor of physics," y- then you will say, "Send us your CV." And you know, if Brian Cox applies, he'll probably get the job, but that's because he's very good at his job, right? It's not because he's a well-known face. In TV,
Hilary Jeffs Partly it is though, isn't it? Because universities, like everyone else, need to make money, and if you've got Brian Cox attached to it, you're gonna get more money
Peter Kinderman Also, to be perfectly honest, I don't want to say anything negative about Brian Cox 'cause I like him, but he probably has quite a cushy job and probably gets paid quite well paid for it. But here's the point. In TV, you can say, you know, we need that person literally because they look right, because their physical attractiveness. So, you know, if you're casting somebody and you want, like on "Countdown," you want somebody to do the numbers and letters, then you are permitted to say as a director producer, "We want somebody who looks physically attractive to do it." And discrimination law doesn't prohibit you from doing that. So again, this idea of the identity of the person and their behavior, and they're chosen on sort of idiosyncratic grounds rather than going through what you might s- they're, they're, they're appointed on the basis of an audition rather than, you know, an appointments panel with selection and criteria and CVs and
Hilary Jeffs Yeah,
Peter Kinderman So everything gets
Hilary Jeffs some, there's been some great recent hit, big wins, haven't there, for some of the older women at the BBC and other organizations where they have gone, "Hang on, actually, I do think you are discriminating against me on the grounds of age."
Peter Kinderman Once they've-- the public recognise, the p-producers go, "Well, that person is indispensable." When they're indispensable, they can get away with bad things, and that's what they do. Yeah.
Hilary Jeffs Well, I mean, it's just so shocking to me as well, especially with Lucy Beaumont saying that she feared that she would be canceled for speaking out. I once lost a radio gig. I was kicked off the show. Well, I wasn't kicked off it, I was just told my contract wouldn't be renewed, but it happened the day after I'd refused to sleep with the owner of the radio station So I was like, "Hmm, let me just see what's going on." But the fact that it's still going on now just beggars belief to me that we still have this fear. And part of it is down to the fact that we've got such a diffusion of responsibility here, because there's not just one organisation. It's not like a school where safeguarding... I was a safeguarding governor of a school. It's actually, whilst it's still a minefield and there's lots of different stakeholders to be able to manage, there is a very clear line of responsibility. There's one organisation, there's one reporting system where it's all collated centrally. You've got everyone going through the same training. You've got everyone from the lunchtime supervisors all the way through to the head all singing from the same hymn sheet. You've got a designated safeguarding lead. But because we've got production companies, we've got actors' agents, we've got guests coming from universities or wherever else to talk as well, we've got just a myriad of freelancers, staffers, different people taking control. There isn't a clear line, is there, of safeguarding reporting?
Peter Kinderman So quite seriously, I mean, this is just simply true. I've got a letter which I probably should have sent on Friday, but I've got a letter that I've drafted for... I mean, I'm, I've, you know, I don't regard-- I'm, I'm not so arrogant as to think that I'm anybody, but I do work in the industry, and I've got a letter drafted to, Lisa Nandy about exactly this, because part of what I do is talk to people in the media. You're, you're absolutely right. There's lots of things that could happen, and the media industry is particularly bad for all sorts of reasons. So one of the reasons is, l-like, like I said, the sort of celebrity power issue. The other thing is, just to pick up on what you said, where you go, you know, "It's terrible that it's perceived that way." It's not just perceived that way, it's true. It-- your story about losing a radio gig is literally true. That's what happens. In a very, very minor way, I tend to work... Myself, I tend to work a lot in news and investigative journalism. I don't work on reality TV shows. And one of the reasons why I don't work on real-reality TV shows is I get occasionally phoned up by producers saying, "Can you screen this person?" And I say, "No. I don't think I should be screening people to see if they're resilient enough to work with that celebrity. You should not make dangerous TV
Hilary Jeffs No, that's terrible. Yeah, absolutely
Peter Kinderman is they employ... The industry employs psychologists and counselors to screen people to appear on TV. So the psychologist says, "I think they're psychologically robust enough to appear on TV." I don't know what that-- I mean, I'm very good at my job. I do not know what that means. And if it means anything at all, it means we're going to abuse this person.
Hilary Jeffs Yep
Peter Kinderman Are, are they more resilient than the average person in surviving abuse? To which the answer is, you should not be abusing people. When I say that to producers, I don't get the gig because what they want is somebody who w-writes a report saying, "This person is psychologically robust," the insurance companies cover it, and then, then disaster happens. But for Lisa Nandy, there are, there are things that can be done. So you're right about the fragmented nature of the industry, and it means that there are producers working, making TV companies, d- TV shows now that were the producers that knew about the abuses of other people in the past. And, you know, they make a TV production company, it's a limited company, and so it's isolated, so that company folds, and then they move on to something else. And it seems that past indiscretions don't inform the future. The industry is voluntary. There are industry standards, and there's an industry standard body, and Nandy was saying at the end of last week that she's considering making it compulsory for media production companies to join this organisation. And that could have the effect of making these things a bit more standardized because you could... If it was mandatory to be a member of it, then you've got the... I mean, it-it's, it's soft government in the sense that, you know, if you're obliged to be a member of a regulatory body and then the regulatory body kicks you out, then logically there will be consequences. So I'm sure the TV industry will, will fight tooth and nail to not have any form of required regulation of their standards, but it should be brought in
Hilary Jeffs Well, I do think there needs to be some kind of central reporting. And actually, what I'm interested in psychologically, Peter, is in schools you have a duty to report, but there's also a culture of reporting. Now which is more important, the culture or the duty? Is it the fact that it's their legal responsibility that you have to do this that's more important than the fact that you know that that's expected of you, it's part of your job, and that's how you should be behaving?
Peter Kinderman So many years ago, I got a job. I'm, I'm really proud of this report. You'll probably find it. Anyway, I wrote a p- report for,... It was in the Department for Constitutional Affairs. It was an offshoot of the Department of Justice, and I wrote a report for them about human rights and what human rights are, and how we can have public services that embody human rights. And when I was working on it, the people working in the human rights field were very positive about the idea of a psychologist commenting on human rights. But what they pointed out was that conceptual issues and understanding and culture have never really worked. What's worked is enforcement. And, you know, I kind of, I kind of take this on board, but you just go, you know, as a psychologist, I've got... When I work, there's quite a lot of paperwork, and the paperwork is tiresome, so I'd really like it if it was a cultural thing. Then a few years later, myself and a colleague, Sarah Bouchard got some money to do some training in care homes. So we were looking at training staff in care homes about human rights, and they-- It was nice training, and we worked with some lovely people to develop this training. So we rolled out this training, which was helping people identify, you know, what it means to lead a dignified life, what respect means, what autonomy means, what freedom means, and how those principles can be applied in nursing homes. What we saw was-- And, you know, we got quite a lot of money to research it. What we saw was very clear, which is when we told people that we were going to be focusing on human rights, then the compliance of the nursing homes improved massively. But not because we were training them, but because they thought their, their records were gonna be looked at. So I think the lawyers are right. I think the culture... It's like the seatbelts, and it's like smoking in pubs. I think unfortunately what we need to do is have leadership, and we need to start by changing the regulations so that the culture changes to match the expectations on that industry
Hilary Jeffs And there's all this worry that like, oh, you know, how will a celebrity, poor celebrity, ever get to have a relationship with someone normal ever again? Because they're always gonna be in a position of power. But it'd be a bit like if a child said something that was worrisome at school, then it has to be reported, and it goes through something called an integrated front door. And then what happens is that you'd get a social worker or someone else looking at that, perhaps having a chat with the caregiver to see what's gone on. It doesn't necessarily mean that all of a sudden y- those children are taken off you. You know, it depends what has gone on. It, what happens is that there is a record kept, and it means that then if, say, a year later, hopefully at the next school when those re- records have seamlessly transferred over, there is another flag, then it's like, okay, so there's a couple of things going on here, and then we can look at it in a different light. Now, what we're saying is not to try and criminalize normal dating behavior. What we wanna do is we need to identify patterns of corrosive behavior
Peter Kinderman Yeah. And you made a point earlier which, which I didn't pick up on, but that's part of, you know, what Lisa Nandy and what the regulatory system in the broadcast industry needs to do, which is it needs to keep a record of allegations and investigations and the outcome of those investigations. And, you know, so in my job, so I'm, I'm, I'm regulated by the Healthcare Professions Council, which is a statutory body, which means that literally if I offend against my professional guidelines, I can literally be handcuffed and arrested and there's the provision for quite a significant criminal sanction if you, if you, if you behave inappropriately. That doesn't mean to say I can't have relationship with people. What it means is if somebody makes an accusation of me, then it's investigated and it's recorded and there's a big leather-bound folio with it in. And that isn't the case in the... It's still rumors and it's still gossip and it's, "Oh, did you know what happened to George at Channel 4?" "No. Tell me what
Hilary Jeffs no single central place to look at this stuff, is there?
Peter Kinderman No. And then, you know, so the idea of, you know, patterns of behavior aren't picked up on, it's just rumors. The idea of saying, you know clearing people. You know, that allegation was made, but it was found, found to be preposterous. So yeah, all of that can follow. So I'm not, no, I'm not worried about celebrities being unable to date ordinary people. I'm, I just think that, yeah, well, the industry need, needs an awful lot more, more regulation, and they're not been very good at regulating themselves, and there's quite a lot that we can do,
Hilary Jeffs And this has been going on a long time now, and it doesn't seem to be getting any better, which is just scandalous, isn't it, really? Look, let's move on before, we run out of time. We saw last week that there was some research which sort of like was pitting one antidepressant against another, which one is better for long-term use. I really want to have a caveat here that you mustn't change your medication or your treatment regime without consulting your medical professional. You know, we are not here to give you particular advice, but we are here to discuss the issues and the wider situation, aren't we, Peter?
Peter Kinderman Yes. So first of all, I mean, well in a couple of things. So, if y- if people Google me, you'll see that I've written quite a lot about mental health issues and about biological theories about mental health issues and about treatments of various kinds including antidepressants. And I'm, I'm connected with those people who are, who are debating this issue quite fervently. Just to go back to your issue of people not stopping or changing medication. No, absolutely not. People shouldn't do that, and they should absolutely do it with medical advice. And usually people should do it much, much slower than they're advised. In my opinion, most medical doctors advise people when they're coming off antidepressants to come off much too quickly. There's a guy called Mark Horowitz, who I think working with a woman called Joanna Moncrieff, who are both extraordinarily clever and competent and ethical, NHS psychiatrists. Mark in particular has developed something called hyperbolic tapering, and it's, it's real science. So it's to do with how antidepressants bond to, bind to the neuroreceptors in your brain. And so when you come off them, you need to come off them in a way that matches the natural physiology of the brain. And it's not complicated. It's basically halve it, then halve it again, then halve it again, and halve it again, but over probably many months in order to come off. So people should absolutely not stop taking the medication, and people should come off it gradually, and people should come off it with medical advice. The other thing to say is, I'm extremely sceptical, as we'll come on to about some of these findings and what they mean and so forth, but that doesn't mean the drugs don't have an effect. I think the drugs do have an effect. They're, they're not just sugar pills. They're not, they're not, you know, worthless. They have a very profound effect on the functioning of your brain, and you should be very cautious about the way in which you take them. But, well, the other final thing to say is, I had the pleasure of sitting on the NICE guidelines committee that developed the recommendations for the NHS and how they use antidepressants, and I've seen a lot of the data. And you know, it's collective sign-up, and I'm very happy with the recommendations made, and I know that the science... Well, the collective view of the science isn't quite as sceptical as my view, and I don't want to, I don't want to undermine my role on that committee by saying I disagree with them. But I was on the sceptical side of the recommendations for the use of antidepressants. I think we need to be much more cautious about them.
Hilary Jeffs Right. Before we get into that then, could we start off by something that is a really basic question, but something I do not understand. What is the difference between low mood, stress, depression, clinical depression? I mean, you know, what is it? 'Cause we can all think I'm- I've got low mood here, but when does it become something called depression?
Peter Kinderman So people differ on this, and you will have different opinions. So if you speak to a traditional or traditionalist psychiatrist, not all psychiatrists hold this point of view, but they will tell you that there is a thing called depression. And I agree, there's a thing called depression. I think it's-- I personally think it's a common human experience. But some psychiatrists would say that there's a phenomenon called depression, which is different from low mood and different from stress, and it's a mental illness, and it has certain criteria, and when you recognise it needs treating. I don't think that's true. I think what we're talking about are human experiences which are common and varied and bleed into each other. So I think that we experience stresses in our lives, and those ex-stress, those stresses impact on us individually in different ways. So for some people, they make it an- make us anxious. I think anxiety is a human experience. I don't think anxiety is an illness that some people have and some people don't. I think sometimes those stresses in our life make us depressed. I think depression is a phenomenon that humans experience from time to time. Some people, unfortunately, experience depression as a phenomenon all their ti- all the time. It's crushingly, devastatingly bad for them, and it affects all aspects of their lives, and that's terrible. I still don't think it's an illness. I think it's an experience that affects our lives in that way. So I don't distinguish between... There was a famous economist who I won't name because I think he's wrong, but he said that 80% of human misery is caused by depression. And I just think this is, that's playing with synonyms and just nonsensical. It's a nonsensical statement to make. So is it true that the experience of depression in humans can have a physiological component? Of course it can, because happiness can have a physiological component. Is it true that when people become very depressed, their thinking changes, their mood changes, their behavior changes, and it tends to be a circular and iterative process? Yes, of course it is. That's, that's the phenomenon that we see. Can depression affect your performance at work and at school and in your relationships? Of course it can Does, do-- are there certain chemicals in the world which when ingested can affect your mood? Yes. I mean, I'm sitting in a room in South Manchester looking out on a street, and I'm very, very well aware of the fact that there are chemicals that you can ingest that affect your mood. Is serotonin associated with experiences of joy and pleasure and reward? Yes, it is. If you play around with serotonin reuptake, does it affect your experience of low mood? Yes, it does. So I think there are human experiences which have been mislabeled as illnesses. There is literally, I'm not saying this as a matter of opinion, I'm stating it as a fact, there is no evidence, not any evidence that the phenomenon that people refer to as depression is a biological illness of the brain. It definitely, definitely isn't associated with a chemical imbalance in the brain that's put right by, by the drugs. The Royal College
Hilary Jeffs have a chemical imbalance in their brain, can't they?
Peter Kinderman It's never been found in a human yet. So that's a statement of a-- yeah, that's a statement of opinion by Hilary.
Hilary Jeffs Oh. Well, no,
Peter Kinderman but it's never, but it, but it's simply
Hilary Jeffs it's... I've had a family member diagnosed with a chemical imbalance, and therefore prescribed medication. I mean, we're going back years and years. I
Peter Kinderman So it,
Hilary Jeffs oh, so that's not a fact, that's just someone has said it? Oh, how
Peter Kinderman that's often, it's a comment that's often made and one of the comments that's been made repeatedly, I mean, thousands of millions of times it's been made, and you will find it all over the internet, that depression is the consequence of a chemical imbalance in the brain. It,
Hilary Jeffs I didn't think all depression was, and indeed w- what this family member, he wasn't diagnosed with depression, he was diagnosed with something else. But, you know, at the end of the day, it
Peter Kinderman and they say it about schizophrenia and they say it about bipolar disorder. It's a common phrase that's made that various things that are labeled as mental illnesses are the consequence of a chemical. Sometimes when you get a sophisticated commentary, then people will say something along the lines of, "Occasionally we're depressed because of the things that happen to us, but in your case, you haven't been able, able to identify any trigger for your problems, and that's because it's a chemical imbalance of the brain. Please take this medication that I'm going to prescribe, and it will rebalance the medication in your brain, making-- the chemicals in your brain, making them..." But there is literally no evidence for it, and the Royal College of, the Ro- Royal College of Psychiatrists has said that that idea is a myth that they don't subscribe to. It's
Hilary Jeffs quite interesting, isn't it? Because it's these different anti-dep- if we stick with depression and low mood at the moment, there are certain different types of medication you can take. So there are these serotonin kind of boosting pills, which are the ones that they featured in the report from last year. These SSRIs, aren't they?
Peter Kinderman There are, yeah, there are SSRIs, serotonin reuptake inhibitors, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors that are used as antidepressants because what they do is they inhibit the reuptake of serotonin, thus boosting the amount of serotonin available in your brain for neurotransmission. However, there is also a class of drugs called selective serotonin reuptake enhancers that work in exactly the opposite way, and they are also used as antidepressants. So go figure
Hilary Jeffs No, but my thing was that I had read that even when your balance of serotonin, you know, where it's been boosted in your brain, your depressive symptoms don't magically go away. So that's where-- Is that what you mean by the fact that it's not a chemical imbalance that is causing this?
Peter Kinderman Well, first of
Hilary Jeffs take away from the experience that people are still having this, and it can crush their lives and can
Peter Kinderman No, absolutely. I
Hilary Jeffs out of bed and they can't move, they can't work, they can't-
Peter Kinderman is, this is my day job. I mean, my day job for 40 years was working with people who experienced these sorts of things that have ruined their lives, and I tried to help them. I just wasn't trying to help them by telling them that it's the product of a chemical imbalance because there is literally no evidence that that's true. And I wasn't trying to help them by giving them chemicals in order to do that thing that can't possibly be true and generally bugger up their neurochemistry, 'cause the drugs are very powerful drugs. But th- no, there is, you know, it just... There are ways of helping people who are experiencing great difficulty without telling them that their great difficulties are as a result of a, of a mythological process. But here's the thing, the drugs really do have powerful effects. So the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, as I say, they inhibit the reuptake of serotonin, which means you've got more serotonin literally sloshing around in your brain. That means that the neurons on the s- kind of the receiving neurons are more likely to depolarize. They're more likely to trigger because you don't have to release as much serotonin from the first neuron to trigger the depolarization of the second neuron because there's already serotonin in the system. So it's, yeah, it's there. What happens, of course, is the brain being a sort of self-regulating organ will, will pick up on the fact, will-- it will receive feedback that its neurotransmitters are being, you know, not being reuptaked. So what it will do is it will down-regulate the sensitivity of serotonin receptors to match the increased availability of serotonin.
Hilary Jeffs Right
Peter Kinderman the brain will... If there were ever a chemical imbalance, then what the brain does is it goes, "Oh, you're trying to do something about the chemical imbalance. I'll just put the chemical imbalance back again." It, the, it's homoregulatory. It's homos- homeostatic. I... You know, there is no evidence that people prone to episodes of depression have a chemical imbalance. What there is evidence is that if you take SSRIs, you will induce a chemical imbalance which may or may not be positive for you, that the brain will then try to rectify by its self-regulatory processes. And what that means is when you stop taking an SSRI, then the inhibitory effect of the SSRI on the reuptake of serotonin will disappear. You will-- Your brain will then start to suck serotonin back into the neurons through the trans- transporter proteins that exist. You'll have less available serotonin for a short period of time, and so when you stop taking the SSRI medication, you'll feel very depressed because you're effectively depriving your brain of serotonin. Well, that's not a relapse. That's the effect of the drugs
Hilary Jeffs And hence why it's so important that if you're going to change the amount of drug you are taking, you have to do it
Peter Kinderman And here's the
Hilary Jeffs brain a chance to catch up
Peter Kinderman Absolutely. So the hyperbolic tapering is you drop the medication, you know, by a third or by half. You wait, you get the side effects of the drop. You basically, you haven't got as much serotonin. You wait until your, your brain readjusts to it, and then you drop again, and then drop again. For very, very many people, and it's a scandal that infuriates me, what happens is people take an antidepressant medication, they feel better, it affects their brain chemistry, it has its effect. They stop taking it, they feel worse, and people tell them, "Yeah, that's the chemical imbalance," which does not exist, "reasserting itself because you are genetically prone to have a bad brain that produce..." And it's not
Hilary Jeffs Well, I read as well, so you can tell me whether this is a myth, that women are... There is more of a genetic component for women's depression 'cause women suffer from it more than men. Whereas men are more susceptible to sort of the community issues that, you know, and those outside factors in the course of their depression or causing depression.
Peter Kinderman Okay. So what I know is that there's been no reliable evidence showing any genetic effects on depression per se. There are some candidate genes that people have put forward for a whole range of so-called mental illnesses that potentially increase the risk for people with this particular variant of genetics a tiny little bit, like by a thousandth of a percent. And if you do massive studies, maybe there are some genes that would put people at, you know, higher risk of low mood, but also greater potential for being a poet, you know, whatever.
Hilary Jeffs It, but is it because women have more empathy then? Or is that also a myth?
Peter Kinderman Okay. So, okay. Right. So there's, there... Right. There's a guy called Thomas Insel.
Hilary Jeffs Yeah
Peter Kinderman Insel was the director of the National Institute of Mental Health in the US. When he stepped down as director of the National Institute of Mental Health, he said that during his 20 years in office, having spent $20 billion on research, they hadn't found a thing that was useful in exploring the biology of mental illness.
Hilary Jeffs Great. Okay. Well, that's
Peter Kinderman that's not me. I mean, I would take it further with, you know, he is, he is, you know, poster boy for biological psychiatry, and he said... He didn't say, "There is no chemical imbalance. We will never find a chemical imbalance." Other people have
Hilary Jeffs you can't say never. You
Peter Kinderman You can't say never. What he said is, "We've spent 20 years and $20 billion of US government money, and we haven't, we haven't moved the needle perceptibly on this subject." Why? So now we go back to, so there is no evidence that depression as a... Which is a real phenomenon, but there's no evidence that the experience of depression i- is in any way usefully explained by chemical imbalance or by genetics. But, you know, you told a story just a few minutes ago about how you as a woman was subjected to quite inappropriate pressure within your industry. I look out of my window and I see an extraordinarily gendered society. I look in, you know, to be honest, I look inside my own home and see a very, very gendered relationship. Could you think of any reason other than genetics and chemical imbalance why women might find the world in which they live depressing? 'Cause I bloody can. I don't need to think. You know, you've got, you've got Russell Brand and Jensen Huang and David Walliams and Boris Johnson, and just, just shits of the first order roaming around. I was hearing a, I was hearing a story that this is related to the Andrew Tate shit that's going on in the world. I was hearing a story that girls 13, 14, 15 are being told that they should wait to be asked out by boys, but the, and that the boys will tell them the nature of the relationship that they're intending to have with them, and then the women get to choose whether to have it or not. And I think, yeah, no, no, no, no, no, no. Hilary, no. That cannot possibly be a depressing experience. That's not the reason for depression. I think there's probably a gene somewhere that's making these girls have a
Hilary Jeffs So it's toxic masculinity coming through again. Okay.
Peter Kinderman Society in which we live. Here's another thing, which, so I went to give a presentation in Sydney, Australia a few years ago, and somebody put their hand up and they said: "Look, you know, I appreciate what you're saying, Peter," but, you know, she was talking about her daughter, I think. But she was going: "Look, there are lots of people who've had charmed lives and nothing terrible has happened to them. Why on earth would we be depressed?" And so I said, "Okay, I'm gonna tell you a thing." About, I don't know, about 1,000 people in the audience. So I said, "I'm gonna tell you a thing." I was very, very gratified by this, by the way, to kind of, you know, tell the end of the anecdote. I leaned forward and went, "I'm gonna tell you a secret. You're all going to die." And rather pleasingly, several people in the audience went, "Ah!" you know, you've,
Hilary Jeffs Like they'd never thought about
Peter Kinderman Yeah. Well, exactly. If you are fully aware of your own mortality, the fact that everything that you hold dear in life will be stripped away from you quite violently by the apparition of death with his scythe, and you look around the world and you realise quite how shit the world is in, what mental techniques do you use to stop yourself being miserable? And those
Hilary Jeffs That's where... Yes. Well, that's where we're going to... Because we're coming to the end of our pod, that is exactly what I want us to go onto next. Because, yes, some people have found some benefit in taking medication.
Peter Kinderman Yeah
Hilary Jeffs know it's not something that you necessarily think is all it's cracked up to be. However, do not change your medication without consulting with your medical team, and also do it very slowly if you do want to change your medication. However, what I'd like from you now, what can we do? It's, it's quite good that we're coming towards a psych hack, 'cause maybe one of them can feature in the psych hack. But what are the changes we can make that is gonna boost those serotonin levels or make other bits... 'Cause it's not just serotonin that we need to increase in our brain. There are other lovely chemicals
Peter Kinderman no, well, and you-- it, that's a bit, that's a bit like having more blue in your TV set. If-- well, you know, if you want a better TV program, you don't add more blue. You do other
Hilary Jeffs Okay, come on then, Professor.
Peter Kinderman Not serotonin, it's,
Hilary Jeffs Give us some 101 on
Peter Kinderman so let's go back to, let's go back to the NICE guidelines, and I, and I won't say these are Peter's views. This is the NICE guidelines. So, okay, yeah, I'm sorry I have to divert, but why on earth are we talking about SSRIs? Because when you look at the NICE guidelines, what they say is, if you want, if you want to feel less depressed, and if you want as a, just as a kind of like throwaway line, boost your serotonin and dopamine levels, do some exercise.
Hilary Jeffs Exercise
Peter Kinderman "I'm so depressed that I can't do exercise." In which case you go, "Look, you know, I appreciate that taking a pill requires less effort than doing some exercise, but seriously, the advice would be do exercise." So top of the list, and it's top of the list in the NICE guidelines, the- their first recommendation is not antidepressants. Their first recommendation is
Hilary Jeffs helpful to necessarily disabled people or people who have severe, ME and things like that. So what can they do?
Peter Kinderman I appreciate that, I appreciate that people with dis-- physical disabilities and people who experience chronic fatigue find it very difficult to exercise. But the truth is that, and this is why professional help is not only the prescription. I am not a specialist physiotherapy working with people with physical disabilities, but I think the NHS should absolutely 100% fund that because the science is still the same, which is if you are living with serious disabilities, it would be a really, really good idea, and you would boost your serotonin levels if you were to be able to receive some professional help in order to do a bit more exercise. And if that's just squeezing a ball with your hand, that's still a good thing. If you have-- if you experience chronic fatigue, then one of the things that we know is that graded exercise is actually extremely good. It is probably the best thing that you can do if you're experiencing chronic fatigue for whatever reason, and I don't know re- the reason why people might experience chronic fatigue. What I do know is that graded exercise is, it's not excellent. I wouldn't go as far as to say it's excellent. It's certainly not guaranteed. But if I or my daughter were identified as experienced chronic fatigue, then graded exercise is what I would want to be offered as an intervention. So both of the examples that you gave, I'm sorry, I disagree. I think that it's much more difficult for people in those categories to do exercise, but exercise will still boost your serotonin. The second thing is that after exercise, I mean, then you go on to things like yoga and so forth, so, you know, simple and accessible yoga would be good. Then the psychological therapies of various kinds, and there are various kinds of therapies, are more effective than the antidepressants.
Hilary Jeffs Such as?
Peter Kinderman Such as cognitive behavior therapy mindfulness-based cognitive therapy cognitive analytic therapies. The basically the talking treatments available on
Hilary Jeffs What about the EMDR? What's that? Eye movement desensitization,
Peter Kinderman Yeah. I mean, that's, that's included. People use EMDR more frequently when there is an identifiable traumatic event that it would be useful for people to kind of reintegrate into their lives. Well, psychedelic...
Hilary Jeffs The line, isn't it?
Peter Kinderman Yeah. Well, psychedelic, psychedelic's coming down the line. So psychedelics do two things. So psychedelics, I mean, basically, if you take a therapeutic dose of a psychedelic drug, you get a massive release of serotonin and dopamine, so you have this extraordinary experience for half an hour in the case of DMT or six hours in the
Hilary Jeffs It's not allowed in this country yet, is it? I don't think. Is it
Peter Kinderman it started-- You have to be on trials, yeah, and, yeah, I mean, it's legal in other countries, but you ha- you have to be on a research trial. I mean, in fact people that I'm close to, are involved in these trials, and I've been involved in these trials as well, so I know, I know the psychedelic trials quite well. The thing about the psychedelics is that well, some people use psychedelic medication at low doses, and it seems to have the same effect as some of the antidepressants in that it perturbs and changes your serotonin system. I vote with Joanna Moncrieff. What these drugs are doing is they're creating an abnormal state. Psychedelics are possibly very useful. My personal opinion is that they're probably useful in that what happens is that they induce a state of mind that involves greater flexibility of thought and the generation of a huge number of hitherto unconsidered perspectives on your current situation. Some of them are sort of mind-blowing and transcendental, and some of them are quite practical. And if what we do is we offer psychological therapy at the same time as a psychedelic experience, what people can do is use that experience to generate massively beneficial new perspectives on their difficulties. So it's like a
Hilary Jeffs I'm far too risk-averse to risk my whole psyche to someone else's. I'm not sure I trust anyone else to take me on that journey. But, you know, I exercise for me. All right, then we'll do exercise.
Peter Kinderman E-exercise is literally as
Hilary Jeffs I like swimming.
Peter Kinderman Yeah, e-exercise is literally scientifically, technically as effective as SSRIs for relieving
Hilary Jeffs a good opportunity to flag up again that we've got a new podcast coming online called Conversations With Experience. So perhaps if you're involved in any of the trials on some of these different therapies that we've been discussing, or perhaps that's what you do for your living, why don't you get in touch with us at hello@experiencepodco.com. Tell us a bit about yourself, and perhaps we can have a chat, the three of us, and work through all the different perspectives, because that's what we're all about. It's about trying to learn deeper things. Now, Peter, before we go then, quick time for a psych hack. Not that you haven't given us some already. What is your psych hack for the day? What are you gonna plumb for?
Peter Kinderman Well, my psych hack relates to the generation effect, which is have a guess first. So, it's, and again, I'm kind of thinking kind of children related where where kids will go, you know, "Why is the sky blue?" And the answer, "Why do you think the sky is blue?" And you know, "What does that button do?" And, "What do you think that button do?" And I, if since we remember things better when we generate themselves, it's better to look things up on Google ask, I mean, ask ChatGPT rather than, you know, and investigate and have a guess and see whether-- and then see whether you're right. So the generation of the answer yourself means that you're likely to remember things better. So,
Hilary Jeffs I've got a
Peter Kinderman of just asking and being passive, have a guess first
Hilary Jeffs My friend says that the worst thing that ever happened to pub chat was the fact that you could just ask Google, because you could spend a whole evening hypothesizing around who was the best footballer or who'd scored the most goals, and it could soak up hours and hours and hours of com- camaraderie male chat. Now all of a sudden someone just gets their phone out, gets the answer, job done. Absolutely hates the fact. Although, in some pubs, I think it's Sam Smith's, is it? You're not allowed to take a phone or use a
Peter Kinderman I, yeah, well, I, again, I have to defend my friends 'cause, 'cause when we go-- when I go to the pub with my friends, what tends to happen is we tend to say: "Who was that actress in 'North by Northwest' who's just died?" And they go, "Was it so and so? And was it so and so? And was it so and so?" And somebody will get it out their phone, and then, then one, somebody will go, "Not yet." And then we'll have a... And then they'll go, and then we'll go, "Right, okay. No, we've... Who is it?" And then you go, "Eva Marie Saint." And you go, "That's it." And then you put the phone down for a while. So we, I think we, I think we're quite good at using our phones and using ChatGPT in a judicious manner to facilitate that
Hilary Jeffs Well, there has been a myriad of psych hacks for you to employ this week. As ever, Peter, thank you so much for your time. Don't forget to have a look out for our conversations with Experience. Also, get in touch if you'd like to sponsor any of our shows, or if you are prepared to take our survey. It's on our website right now, which is experiencepodco.com. We wanna know a little bit more about you. Thank you very much for watching